The 5776 (2015-2016) cycle of Dvar Tzedek is a special one. To commemorate AJWS’s 30th anniversary, we are sharing a selection of some of our favorite commentaries from past years. Each legacy commentary will be introduced with a related reflection on AJWS’s work and contemporary issues.
In Parashat Pinchas, the Torah tells a story of five sisters who are about to lose all of their family inheritance because their father never had a son. With no male heir, his land holdings would be forfeited. These women bring their case before Moses and demand that the law be changed. Moses offers no response and brings the matter before God.
Rachel Farbiarz explains in her 2009 Dvar Tzedek: “While the daughters of Zelophehad seem emboldened by their grievance, it only silences their leaders. The sisters’ cause appears righteous, but its remedy is simply unthinkable in a society that numbers only its men. Into this mute vacuum comes the Divine ruling.”
Not only do the sisters get to keep the family inheritance, but their example changes the law. As the Torah amends: “If a man dies without a son, then his inheritance shall pass to his daughter.” Farbiarz comments, “That it took the voice of God to resolve the sisters’ complaint reveals just how profoundly audacious—and brave—was their demand.”
Women’s access to land isn’t simply about inheritance. It is a foundation for women’s safety and wellbeing, as the activists of Guatemalan women’s organization and AJWS grantee Nuevo Horizonte (New Horizons) explained to AJWS’s Director of Natural Resource Rights, Nikhil Aziz.
“[Women] are providers and caretakers for their families,” said Maria Luisa Chocoj, one of Nuevo Horizonte’s organizers. “They’re concerned with livelihoods. So we begin there.” Nuevo Horizonte has focused on teaching women farming skills that make the most of the local soil and climate and achieve food sovereignty—the ability to live sustainably off of what they grow. “But we can’t have food sovereignty without land,” interjected Herlinda Caal, another organizer. “So we work on land rights for women and also environmental issues because our work is premised on the concept of agroecology.” Nuevo Horizonte also addresses gender-based violence and reproductive rights, because protecting women’s health and well-being is integral to the survival of their communities in Guatemala.
Like the daughters of Zelophehad, who insisted that women, too, have a claim to the land, the women of Nuevo Horizonte have given Guatemalan women the tools to grow, nourish and cultivate their own farms, fields and bodies, leading to a healthier, more sustainable society for all. Read more about their story here, and explore Rachel Farbiarz’s Dvar Tzedek below.
After decades of the Israelites’ wanderings, God’s decree upon the willful generation of the Exodus—“In this very wilderness shall your carcasses drop”—is nearly fulfilled. To take stock of the new generation born in the desert, a census is ordered. Lineages are recorded; tribes’ sums inscribed; fresh tallies of the war-ready men collected. And from among these men, God charges, “shall the land be apportioned as shares, according to the listed names.”
Against this backdrop—the work of the census complete, the law of the land’s division laid down—come five women: the daughters of Zelophehad, a sonless Manassite who died for his sins in the desert. The sisters demand a landed inheritance alongside the newly-numbered men. “Let not our father’s name be lost to his clan just because he had no son!” they lament. “Give us a holding among our father’s kinsmen!”
The women present themselves for judgment before the “whole assembly” at the Tabernacle’s entrance. They bring their case to the tribes’ chieftains, to the high priest Eleazar and to Moses. They are stubborn, these sisters—a “stiff-necked” cabal of five, undaunted by the only inheritance they have received until now: the cautionary knowledge that they are the progeny of a people annihilated for their murmuring complaints, the daughters of a sinner buried in the desert.
While the daughters of Zelophehad seem emboldened by their grievance, it only silences their leaders. The sisters’ cause appears righteous, but its remedy is simply unthinkable in a society that numbers only its men. Into this mute vacuum comes the Divine ruling: “Rightly do the daughters of Zelophehad speak. You shall surely give them a secure holding in the midst of their father’s brothers and you shall pass on their father’s estate to them.” And then God reshapes the law in its entirety, commanding Moses: “And to the Israelites you shall speak, saying: ‘Should a man die without having a son, you shall pass on his estate to his daughter.’”
That it took the voice of God to resolve the sisters’ complaint reveals just how profoundly audacious—and brave—was their demand. That this would-be dispossession is a reality for millions of women around the globe today reveals just how deeply entrenched in law and practice is the preference for men over women in matters of property and landed inheritance.
Throughout much of today’s developing world, men overwhelmingly control access to the arable land, with estimates of female ownership at an abysmal 2% in Africa. While women are legally prohibited from holding title in countries such as Malawi, female ownership and control elsewhere is more broadly barred through custom, culture and family. Unsurprisingly, problems are particularly acute surrounding inheritance and death. In one emblematic, ancient-sounding story whose contours are outrageously common today, a Ugandan woman tells of how within a month of her husband’s death, she was chased by her in-laws from the land she had long shared with her husband. The widow returned to her childhood home, only to be confronted by her brother, who had legally inherited the plot from their now-deceased parents. He, in turn, chased away his destitute sister and her five children.
But the stakes are even higher than the tremendous indignity visited upon this widow. Because women produce up to 80% of the developing world’s food, insecurity in women’s access to land translates into insecurity in the food supply. A productive harvest that may have fed an entire network of families can easily evaporate when a woman is disinherited or evicted. Without secure tenure, women are often unable “to borrow small amounts of money to buy seeds and other essential inputs” and are “excluded from training and farmers’ cooperatives.” Hunger and poverty are the starkly inevitable outcomes under these perversely unjust ownership regimes.
We cannot, of course, rely on a Divine ruling to reshape the laws and practices that bar women from secure access to land. We can, however, support the modern-day daughters of Zelophehad—support typified by the organization Elgar Prathisthan, an AJWS grantee. Elgar Prathisthan works with marginalized tribal women in Maharashtra, India to attain control and title over their land and to recover land that has been unlawfully taken from them. Along with raising awareness of these issues, the organization also presses the government to protect the land rights of vulnerable communities and populations.
We can hope that the efforts of stiff-necked and strong-willed people, like those who work with Elgar Prathisthan, will one day obsolesce the daughters of Zelophehad—transforming their story from global reality into arcane tale, merely a curious memory in a world more bountiful and just.
1 Numbers 14:29.
2 Numbers 26:53, 26:1-56.
3 Numbers 27:1-4.
4 Numbers 27:2-3.
5 Numbers 27:6-8.
6 “Women’s Right to Land and Livelihoods,” Hanstad, Tim. “Opinion: Access to Land Improves Women’s Lives Around the World,” The Seattle Times, 10 Mar. 2009. http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/opinion/2008837349_opinc11hanstad.html; Gerntholtz, Liesl. “Women’s Land Rights Can Help Battle Hunger in Africa,” The Boston Globe, 19 Mar. 2009. http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2009/03/19/womens_land_rights_can_help_battle_hunger_in_africa/.
7 Masina, Lameck. “Women in Malawi Hope to End Land Ownership Discrimination,” VOANews.com, 9 Feb. 2009.
8 Jane Nafula, “Uganda: No Land for Women; the Attitude Behind Hunger,” The Monitor, 29 Oct. 2008. http://allafrica.com/stories/200810290257.html.
9 “Women Worldwide Taking Action to End Hunger,” ActionAid, 2 Mar. 2009. Rekha Mehra and Mary Rojas, “A Significant Shift: Women, Food Security and Agriculture in a Global Marketplace” International Center for Research on Women, 2008. http://www.icrw.org/docs/2008/a-significant-shift-women-food security-and-agriculture FINAL.pdf.